Linda Crampton is a writer and teacher with a first-class honors degree in biology. She often writes about the scientific basis of disease.
Herniated Disks and Bacteria
A herniated or slipped disk in the spine is often a painful condition. The outer part of the disk ruptures, and the inner part protrudes and presses on a nerve. Physical therapy and anti-inflammatory medicines frequently reduce the pain and help the body to heal itself. Unfortunately, sometimes the pain persists and the problem becomes chronic. In this situation, spinal surgery may be recommended.
Researchers from the University of Southern Denmark have found bacterial infections in some herniated disks. They believe that 20% to 40% of chronic back pain cases associated with a herniation are produced by a bacterial infection. The scientists also say that antibiotics (or at least the one that they tested) can reduce the pain.
Some investigators are intrigued by the possibility of a link between bacteria and back pain caused by a herniated disk. Other investigators besides the Danish ones have found bacteria in damaged disks. Some scientists haven't found bacteria in the disks, however, and they suspect that there have been procedural errors in some experiments. More research is necessary to clarify the situation.
Seven cervical vertebrae are found in the neck, twelve thoracic ones in the upper back, five lumbar ones in the lower back, five fused ones in the sacrum, and three to five fused ones in the coccyx. According to the Mayo Clinic, most herniated disks occur in the lower back, but some occur in the neck.
A Spinal or Intervertebral Disk (or Disc)
Some people refer to rules stating when "disk" and "disc" should be used, but these rules aren't universally followed. I refer to a spinal "disk" like MedlinePlus (a National Institutes of Health site) and the Mayo Clinic often do, but the spelling is really a matter of personal preference.
Disks are short, cartilaginous cylinders that are located between the vertebrae, or bones, of the spine. They lie on top of the body of a vertebra. The disks absorb shock created by movements such as running and jumping and also prevent the vertebrae from grinding against each other and breaking down.
The parts of a spinal disk are listed and described below. They are shown in the illustration above and in the first image in this article.
- The annulus fibrosis is the tough and fibrous outer surface of the disk.
- The nucleus pulposus is the gelatinous inner portion of the disk.
- The nucleus pulposus is made of loosely arranged fibers in a gel made of molecules called mucoprotein.
- Mucoproteins consist of both protein and a type of carbohydrate called a glycosaminoglycan. Glycosaminoglycans make liquids viscous.
What Is a Herniated Disk?
Back pain may be due to arthritis or a problem with back muscles, ligaments (which attach bones to one another), or tendons (which attach muscles to bones). A doctor's diagnosis is needed to identify the cause of back pain and to confirm that a back problem is actually due to a herniated disk.
Herniated disks are also known as slipped, ruptured, or prolapsed disks. A slipped disk hasn't moved out of place, despite its name. Instead, the outer layer of the disk has ruptured, allowing the softer inner tissue to bulge outwards. A prolapse is a condition in which an entire organ moves out of place. The term "herniated disk" is probably the best one in reference to the spine because it's the most accurate. A hernia is a condition in which part of an organ protrudes through the structure that encloses it.
The body attempts to heal the broken surface of a disk and remove the expelled material. Before the area is repaired, however, the person may be in pain. The pain arises due to the inner tissue of the disk pressing on a spinal nerve and irritating it.
Herniated disks are most common in middle-aged people. Being overweight increases the risk of a disk rupture. A sudden strain or repetitive activities may be the immediate cause of the injury, however.
Possible Symptoms of a Herniated Disk
Some people have no symptoms from a herniated disk. The rupture may be small or may not affect a nerve. In other people, there may be pain for a while, but the pain may disappear as the body repairs the rupture and breaks down the material that was released from the disk. The healing process may take weeks or even months. Unfortunately, some people experience chronic (long-term) pain from a herniated disk.
The nerve irritation caused by the hernia can produce pain, numbness, and tingling. There may also be weakness in the muscles controlled by the affected nerves. If a disk in the neck is herniated, the pain often appears in a shoulder and arm. If the damaged disk is in the lower back, the person frequently feels pain in their buttocks, thigh, and leg. Sometimes pain will appear in the foot, too.
If the pressure on a nerve in the lower back is intense, the person may lose control of urination or defecation. These conditions are medical emergencies and require immediate attention. Coughing, sneezing, laughing, urinating, and defecating can all increase the pain from a herniated disk.
Bacteria and Chronic Back Pain
The results of the Danish experiment seem to have intrigued many researchers. Some scientists have concerns about the discoveries, however. They say that despite the careful techniques used in the Danish experiment, bacteria may have appeared in their disk samples due to contamination. This possibility shouldn't be discounted. The idea that bacteria are present in herniated disks is very interesting, though.
The research done so far suggests that in order for an intervertebral disk to be infected by bacteria (if this actually happens), it must first rupture. The rupture causes the initial pain when the contents of the disk affect a nerve. The Danish researchers say that as the body heals the injury, blood vessels extend into the disk. Bacteria in the blood can therefore enter the disk, where they multiply and cause an infection. Inflammation, swelling, and tiny fissures have been observed in the bones of the vertebrae around herniated disks. The investigators believe that bacterial infections cause these conditions.
One treatment for a herniated disk that's causing continuous problems is to surgically remove the displaced tissue. The Danish researchers examined the spinal tissue taken from people who had undergone surgery for chronic back pain. They followed "stringent antiseptic sterile protocols" to avoid contamination of the samples with bacteria from another source. The researchers found that nearly half of the samples were infected by bacteria. In addition, they discovered that more than eighty percent of the infected samples contained a bacterium called Propionibacterium acnes—the same bacterium that is involved in acne. The bacterium is sometimes known as Cutibacterium acnes.
Propionibacterium acnes normally lives on our skin, in our mouths, and in our large intestine. It can also enter our blood. The researchers think that the bacterium travels to damaged spinal disks in the bloodstream and then releases chemicals that trigger inflammation.
Testing the Use of Antibiotics for Pain Relief
In another experiment, the Danish researchers gave antibiotics to people who had suffered from back pain for at least six months and had evidence of spinal disk damage and vertebral swelling around the damage. (The subjects weren't tested for the presence of bacteria in their spine.) Other people with these same conditions were given a placebo.
Antibiotic treatment for 100 days reduced pain and other problematic conditions significantly in people given an antibiotic compared to those given a placebo. The increased benefits were still present and in some cases had even improved one year after the initial evaluation.
It's important to note that the people in the test had specific problems in their spine. Antibiotics haven't yet been tested on other people with back pain. In addition, since the overuse of antibiotics has led to frightening resistance to the medications in bacteria, it's vital that antibiotics aren't prescribed for back pain patients "just in case" they help them.
There is a suspicion that some categories of antibiotics can reduce inflammation in addition to reducing infection. Reducing inflammation when no bacteria were present may have reduced pain in the Danish experiment.
Some Possible Problems in the Research
Research involving humans is often difficult because so many factors are involved. For example, bacteria are tiny and ubiquitous creatures and often appear where they're not wanted. Very careful procedures are needed to prevent contamination of a tissue sample when the sample is extracted or examined.
Good experiments use a placebo. A placebo is a harmless substance that has no medical benefit when administered to a patient. Some subjects in an experiment are given a placebo and some are given the test treatment. The subjects don't know which type of treatment they are receiving. This procedure enables the researchers to take the "placebo effect" into account when analyzing the results of the experiment. Sometimes knowing that something may help us enables us to feel better, even when the treatment has no known benefit.
All experiments involving humans need to be double blind. A double blind experiment is one in which neither the subjects nor the person administering a treatment know its identity. Unfortunately, the Danish antibiotic experiment may not have been completely double blind. Some of the subjects that were given antibiotics may have suspected that they had received a medication because they experienced diarrhea as a side effect of the treatment. This suspicion may have affected the outcome of the experiment.
As strong as this research is, it is not definitive.
— NHS (National Health Service) with respect to the 2013 study
Surveys of Scientific Literature
The Danish research was reported in 2013. Since that time, other researchers have found bacteria in herniated disk material. In 2015, a group of Australian doctors and researchers analyzed the scientific literature with respect to the possible link between bacteria in herniated disks and chronic pain. They found that bacteria are commonly detected in herniated disks. They say that at the moment there is "modest" evidence supporting the idea that the bacteria contribute to a patient's pain. They also say that further research is needed to demonstrate that the bacteria that have been discovered are not the result of tissue contamination.
A 2019 study published in the European Spine Journal also explored the relevant scientific literature. The investigators noticed the heterogeneity (different conditions) used in the studies. Tissue is taken from a patient's injured disk during surgery and then cultured to see if bacteria are present. One problem that the investigators observed was the variation in sampling techniques. Another was that different culture conditions were used in different experiments. Some of the conditions may not have supported the survival or growth of Propionibacterium acnes.
Despite the problems mentioned above, the investigators noted that bacteria were found in a significant number of disk samples. They concluded that bacteria might cause disk pain, but this is uncertain due to the heterogeneity of the experimental conditions.
A Controversial Topic
While the results of the Danish investigations are interesting and have impressed many people, they don't prove that bacteria contribute to the pain of herniated disks. The source of the bacteria and the effects of different types of antibiotics need to be clarified. Even if bacteria are present in damaged disks, it doesn't necessarily mean that they are responsible for the patient's pain.
Some scientists believe that it's highly likely that bacteria found in tissue from herniated disks are present due to contamination of the samples during the testing process. Some researchers have looked for bacteria in damaged disks and found none, and some have found that at least some antibiotics don't help patients' pain. Other researchers are not so certain that the presence of bacteria in herniated disk tissue is due to contamination and believe that more studies under specific conditions are necessary.
I hope the situation is clarified. If bacteria do play a role in some people's pain, we need to know this. On the other hand, continuing to explore the idea might not be the best use of some researchers' time. Investigating other ways to help people with disk pain might be a more effective use of time and money. It would be wonderful if doctors one day have another treatment—or even multiple treatments—to offer people who are suffering from back pain due to a herniated disk.
- Herniated disk facts from MedlinePlus, U.S. National Library of Medicine
- Information about herniated disks from the Mayo Clinic
- The report about bacteria in disks from the Danish researchers in the European Spine Journal (via the National Institutes of Health or NIH)
- Antibiotics may help ease chronic back pain (An analysis of the Danish research by the National Health Service: 2013 report)
- An analysis of research projects linking bacteria to herniated disk pain published by the NIH: 2015 report
- Bacteria in disk tissue samples from the European Spine Journal: 2019 report
This content is accurate and true to the best of the author’s knowledge and does not substitute for diagnosis, prognosis, treatment, prescription, and/or dietary advice from a licensed health professional. Drugs, supplements, and natural remedies may have dangerous side effects. If pregnant or nursing, consult with a qualified provider on an individual basis. Seek immediate help if you are experiencing a medical emergency.
Questions & Answers
Question: What causes a herniated disk with a pinched nerve? What should I do about it?
Answer: The term “pinched nerve” is very common, but it’s not a medical term. It refers to any situation in which pressure is put on a nerve or in which a nerve is stretched. There are multiple causes of the condition. One cause is pressure on a nerve root created by a herniated disk. The root of a nerve is the location where it leaves the central nervous system (brain or spinal cord). A pinched nerve may cause pain, tingling, or numbness. A doctor should be consulted for help if these symptoms are present.
Question: Could herniated disk pain cause dizziness?
Answer: I have read articles written by medical professionals that say that it may in specific situations. It's very important that anyone who is experiencing dizziness visits a doctor for a diagnosis, however. Dizziness can be caused by many problems and may have nothing to do with the herniated disk in a patient. A patient with pain from a herniated disk should never assume that the problem is responsible for their dizziness. It may be, but on the other hand the dizziness may be caused by a different problem that needs to be treated.
© 2013 Linda Crampton
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on March 06, 2018:
You need to ask a doctor this question, nazie. I'm a science writer, not a health practitioner, so I can't advise you. Please visit your doctor as soon as possible to get treatment and prevent further injury.
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on February 18, 2018:
You should see your doctor as soon as possible to get a diagnosis and treatment, Brenda.
Brenda bobo on February 18, 2018:
Had back pain in July 2017 my left uper thigh is numb.back not in pain now but legs are in pain and numb ?
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on August 01, 2013:
I am so sorry for what you are going through, CJGrace. I very much hope that you find a new doctor who can give you the help that you need. My best wishes to you. I hope healing happens very soon.
Chris from California on August 01, 2013:
Awesome article. I've had a major problem since a car accident in '08. I have two bulging disks in my lower back, a broken back, sciatica, scoliosis, and now due to my age, arthritis, and disgenerative disease. The problem has spread to my neck now too. The nerve damage is so bad, I feel it down to my feet. I feel like I have the shoe on the wrong foot. Three years after the accident, I bent to pick something up, and not only did I feel a snap, I heard it too. I lost bodily function control. I still have not had surgery, just pain meds. I just moved and need to get in with a new doctor. I know what pain is and I feel for anyone who suffers.
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on August 01, 2013:
Thank you very much for the comment, Audrey. I hope that you find more permanent relief for your sciatica. I appreciate the share!
Audrey Hunt from Idyllwild Ca. on August 01, 2013:
Great news! I, too suffer from chronic sciatica. I've had physical therapy but the improvement only seems to last for a short time. Stretching, walking and limited sitting at the computer gives me temporary relief. Really like the information in your hub. You are very kind to share this.
Thanks and sharing!
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on July 12, 2013:
I'm sorry about your slipped disks, always exploring. Having one is bad enough, but having two slipped disks is horrible! I'm glad that you've found ways to relieve the pain. Thanks for the comment.
Ruby Jean Richert from Southern Illinois on July 12, 2013:
This is wonderful news. I have two herniated disks, 4th and 5th lumbar. I find that stretching and yoga are two exercises that relieve pain. Thank you for an informative hub.
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on May 30, 2013:
The research does sound promising. I hope it helps people with herniated disks. Thanks for the comment, drbj.
drbj and sherry from south Florida on May 30, 2013:
The new Swedish research, Alicia, seems very promising, especially if it will prevent invasive surgery in patients with severe back pain. Thanks for this scientific heads-up.
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on May 19, 2013:
Hi, Deb. Yes, I know someone who doesn't do anything about pain until they absolutely have to! Thank you for the comment.
Deb Hirt from Stillwater, OK on May 19, 2013:
Great work, Alicia. I'm sure a lot of people out there with back pain will like to read this, as it can give them a heads up on what is wrong. Many people tell friends about the pain, but usually don't do anything until they are forced to do so.
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on May 18, 2013:
Thanks for the comment and the vote, Nell. I appreciate your visit. Herniated disks sound like they can be very painful!
Nell Rose from England on May 18, 2013:
Great information Alicia, I never knew about the bacteria involvement. My brother had a bad back, slipped disc a few years ago, and the pain he was in was awful. I did my back in once years ago, and its not a pleasant thing to do, took me ages to recover, I was carrying bags of shopping and just twisted as I put them down, the ironic thing was that I did weightlifting at the time and that didn't hurt it! voted up, nell
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on May 18, 2013:
Thank you for such a wonderful comment, Martie! I appreciate it very much. I hope the doctors find the cause for your leg pain. It must be so frustrating - as well as painful - to continue experiencing leg problems with no effective treatment being offered.
Martie Coetser from South Africa on May 18, 2013:
Very interesting! My doctor's suspicion that this could be the reason for the cronic, painful swelling of my legs has been refuted by X-rays. So we are still searching for the real cause.
Very interesting, informative and well-written article about slipped disks, bacteria and back pain. Voted up and higher :)
Thank you, Alicia. Your hubs are feathers in HubPages's cap :)
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on May 17, 2013:
What a horrible injury, cloverleaffarm! Thank you for sharing your very interesting experience. Walking was a wonderful alternative to surgery!
Healing Herbalist from The Hamlet of Effingham on May 17, 2013:
I had 3 herniated disks with a loose bone fragment. The pain was horrendous. My doctor told me I had two options; surgery or walking. Either one would have the same outcome. I chose walking. I walked up to four miles a day (that is what I worked up to). I not only healed my back, but I lost weight.
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on May 16, 2013:
Thanks for the comment and for sharing the interesting and useful information, RTalloni. I appreciate the pin, too! I hope that you're able to continue dealing with your back pain successfully.
RTalloni on May 16, 2013:
Very interesting info. I keep thinking that if I wait long enough a discovery will be made that could prevent invasive treatment. Maybe… :)
Choosing chiropractic care over surgery in past years has been a helpful choice for me, but since I've used a balance ball chair I get wonderful relief when in trouble just by sitting (correctly) on it and I think it helps keep me from having as much trouble as I used to have with the disc problem.
Pinning to my Back Pain board.
Linda Crampton (author) from British Columbia, Canada on May 16, 2013:
That sounds like a very unpleasant experience, Bill. I'm glad that the operation solved the problem. I hope that I never experience a herniated disk. Thanks for the comment (and the pun)!
Bill Holland from Olympia, WA on May 16, 2013:
Good information, Alicia. I had a back operation in 1989 for a herniated disk....all has been well since then, but it was more painful than anything I have ever experienced. I literally could not walk. So glad that is behind me. :) Kind of a pun. LOL